An Extra Slice Of New York

Discover An Extra Slice Of New York Pizza in Manor, PA, offering authentic NY-style pizza, delicious meatballs, garlic knots, white pizza, chicken parm, and more. Experience true Italian flavor today!

Welcome to An Extra Slice Of New York

Signature Dining Experience

An Extra Slice Of New York
An Extra Slice Of New York
An Extra Slice Of New York
An Extra Slice Of New York

Located at 40 Race St, Manor, PA, An Extra Slice Of New York serves delicious, authentic New York-style pizza that's hard to resist. Known for its flavorful pies and hearty portions, this pizzeria quickly becomes a neighborhood favorite. Whether craving a classic cheese slice, a variety of specialty pizzas, or some delightful garlic knots, this spot answers every pizza lover’s wishes.

Open daily, the restaurant maintains a lively atmosphere that feels both inviting and reminiscent of bustling NYC eateries. Diners community often gather here, sharing stories and savoring the unforgettable taste that brings a slice of New York right to their plates.

Location & Contact

Address

40 Race St, Manor, PA 15665, United States

Phone

+1 724-861-0818

About

An Extra Slice Of New York
An Extra Slice Of New York
An Extra Slice Of New York
An Extra Slice Of New York

An Extra Slice Of New York stands out not just for its pizza, but for its community-centric approach that feels like an extension of a living room. The restaurant thrives on the energetic spirit of Manor, PA, enriching the local culinary landscape with every slice served. The menu reflects an expansive variety of options designed to satisfy everyone from casual diners to pizza aficionados.

Each item tells a story of culinary craftsmanship, from their hand-tossed dough to the special house sauces.

Signature pizzas like the Vodka and White Pizza exhibit sophisticated flavor profiles, proving that pizza can be more than just a quick meal. Meatball and ricotta rolls evoke memories of traditional Italian kitchens, prepared with family recipes and served with love. The commitment to authenticity resonates through each dish, creating a positive dining experience that encourages customers to return time and again.

Community involvement is part of the core values here.

Regular pizza nights and special events foster a sense of unity among neighbors, making it a place where connections are made over shared meals. As each pizza is pulled from the oven, the aroma fills the air, creating an atmosphere of anticipation shared among everyone present, whether they are sitting down for a meal or picking up an order to go.

Work Hours

  • Sunday11 AM-8 PM
  • MondayClosed
  • Tuesday3-8 PM
  • Wednesday3-8 PM
  • Thursday3-8 PM
  • Friday11 AM-8 PM
  • Saturday11 AM-8 PM

An Extra Slice Of New York boasts an impressive menu filled with diverse pizza offerings. Patrons can choose from 12" and 18" options of Regular and Sicilian pizzas, with average prices ranging from $16 to $28.50. Each pizza is made fresh, topped with high-quality ingredients, ensuring each bite is a flavor explosion. But pizza isn't the only star here. The establishment also serves delightful dough rolls filled with savory options like pepperoni and chicken parmesan, all for around $19.80.

Sides like garlic knots and a refreshing Caprese salad, priced at about $8.75, complement the main courses nicely.

With 20 total dishes, including different toppings, An Extra Slice Of New York truly caters to diverse tastes. Plus, a casual atmosphere welcomes everyone, perfect for family dinners or late-night pizza runs.

An Extra Slice Of New York

The exterior of An Extra Slice Of New York is inviting, adorned with vibrant signage that beckons pizza enthusiasts inside. A cozy outdoor seating area creates the perfect setting for enjoying a slice under the stars. This relaxed vibe pairs well with the lively atmosphere inside, filled with laughter and the sounds of pizza being crafted right in front of you. Customers feel at home whether they're dining in or placing a quick takeout order.

Customer Reviews

We love this place! We only use high quality and REAL ingredients at home so we don't stray often when eating out. This is our favorite place because the measures they take to ensure we're eating quality REAL food! Our daughter has a dairy allergy so we order a small pizza for her without cheese every time and it's her favorite thing ever that she looks forward to most. I love how kind they are in the process and never treat it as an ordeal. They go above and beyond for their customers and the pizza is the best.

L
Loran C.

My husband, kids, and I went for the first time on 2/14. Ordered 2 pizzas; a margarita and a sweet and spicy. The wait time was 25 min, so we went to the car until they were ready. They brought the pizzas out to the car because they got them done earlier than they said. Straight from the oven and had a mini pizza party in the car. Absolutely perfect; crispy base, crispy and fluffy crust, perfect amount of sauce to cheese/toppings ratio. After devouring a couple slices, we headed the 40 min home and just had to go in for round 2; they were still amazing even after the drive. Will definitely be planning a stop back in the near future!

T
Tara M.

Went in not knowing what to expect. I knew it was part of the Murrysville, PA location, but I just didn't know how related. They are a franchise of it. They are using different ovens, but the recipe seems the same. I decided to try a white pizza with pesto and ricotta. It turned out pretty good, very tasty. Could have been cooked a bit longer as the bottom needed a bit more time in the oven. Overall, good pie, regardless. Staff was friendly and interested in conversation, all while kicking orders out. Small business, but for the 10 minutes I was there, 4 customers came in with orders for pickup or to be placed. They do slices here, which is great. The one in Murrysville both times I went, neither time was slices available. I definitely recommend this place if you're nearby.

V
Vaughn

Customer service and pizza is amazing. I always get the regular pizza and garlic knots. The regular pizza is perfect NY pizza. Very large slices, garlic knots taste so fresh! You can tell everything is made fresh! The people are always so nice and thoughtful when I go in. Today I was offered free Italian soup! If you want pizza I would go here. Also, Dave Portnoy who reviews pizza around USA gave them a 8.2 rating which is so high, so another reason to know it's good!

C
Caitlin P.

Guy who made the pizza was very friendly and cool. My husband and i always order lightly baked ny style pies because we seem to be of the few that don't really like char/black spots on pizza so and he showed me our pie right out of the oven and asked if it looked good, and it was PERFECT. It had a crispy crust that was soft inside, cheese was def top quality, sauce was tasty (only thing was could maybe use a tad more sauce for us) pepperoni was delicious and they didn't skimp on it! We will absolutely be returning and throwing this in our pizza rotation. Also their Sicilian looks amazing so that'll be on our list to try!

K
Karen B.

Fantasticly high quality ingredients make pizza of this caliber. Honestly, don't waste your time going to any other pizza shop where they use low cost or low quality ingredients and skip out on the 72-hour ferment. This pizza won't make you feel like garbage, good in, good out. Exceptionally friendly owner and atmosphere. The Northern California tomatoes and the excellent quality cheese paired with the fermented dough crispy crust is what you deserve. Don't settle for cheap garbage, do yourself a favor and order from here.

D
Douglas C.